There’s something special about fresh, local dairy, especially when it comes from a family that’s been caring for their farm for generations. That’s exactly why we’re proud to carry Apple Valley Creamery products at Locals’ Market. From their rich whole milk to their fan-favorite chocolate milk and seasonal orange cream milk, every bottle reflects their commitment to quality, animal care, and local agriculture.

Here’s a closer look at the family behind the dairy and why we’re excited to bring their products to our shelves.

Who They Are

Located in East Berlin, Pennsylvania, Apple Valley Creamery is a sixth-generation family dairy farm owned and operated by the Stoner family. Since opening their creamery in 2005, they’ve focused on connecting families with fresh, locally produced dairy while caring for both their animals and the land they’ll pass on to future generations.

Their philosophy is simple: produce wholesome, premium dairy products using responsible farming practices and share them with their local community.

What Makes Apple Valley Creamery Different?

Apple Valley isn’t just another dairy farm, either! Their cows are independently certified through the Animal Welfare Approved program, one of the country’s highest animal welfare certifications. They also grow and feed only non-GMO crops to their herd, ensuring quality starts long before the milk reaches the bottle.

Unlike many large-scale dairies, Apple Valley minimally processes their milk using flash pasteurization to preserve its fresh taste and quality. They also offer cream line (non-homogenized) milk, allowing the cream to naturally rise to the top—just like milk used to be enjoyed.

What You’ll Find at Locals’ Market

We’re proud to stock several of Apple Valley Creamery’s most popular dairy products, including:

• Raw Milk*
• Whole Milk
• Chocolate Milk
• Orange Cream Milk

Whether you’re pouring a cold glass with dinner, baking family recipes, or simply enjoying a nostalgic treat, these local favorites bring exceptional flavor to every sip.

*Raw milk is sold in accordance with Pennsylvania regulations and requires additional safety testing before being offered for sale.

A Seasonal Favorite

One product customers ask about year after year is Apple Valley’s Orange Cream Milk.

Made to taste just like a classic orange creamsicle, this seasonal favorite combines rich whole milk with bright citrus flavor for a nostalgic treat that’s unlike anything you’ll find in the average grocery store. Apple Valley rotates this flavor throughout the year alongside other specialty offerings, making it a fun surprise whenever it returns.

Of course, their famous chocolate milk remains a year-round customer favorite.

Why We Love Partnering with Apple Valley Creamery

At Locals’ Market, we’re passionate about supporting farms that care about quality just as much as we do.

Apple Valley Creamery shares our values by:

• Supporting sustainable family farming
• Prioritizing animal welfare
• Producing fresh local dairy
• Keeping food close to home
• Delivering exceptional flavor with minimal processing

When you purchase Apple Valley products from Locals’ Market, you’re supporting a Pennsylvania family farm that’s dedicated to doing things the right way.

Bring Home a Taste of Local

Whether you’re picking up fresh whole milk for breakfast, chocolate milk for the kids, or hoping to catch the return of their orange cream milk, Apple Valley Creamery delivers the kind of quality that only comes from a local family farm.

Stop by Locals’ Market and discover why Apple Valley Creamery has become one of our favorite dairy partners. Fresh, wholesome, and proudly Pennsylvania-made, it’s local dairy at its very best!